Browntown Tier List Tier List

  • A NOTICE REGARDING TIER LISTS:

    Please note that all tier lists (especially those made by Tyber) are heavily biased (many on flawed logic) and should not be taken as official or the community's stance on the rankings.

Putin

Active member
Legendary
Donator
Jul 22, 2020
25
23
30
22
Virginia
It's time. We've seen a lot of tier lists these past few days. It can be hard to even keep track. Well I went through them all so you don't have to. Here it is, a comprehensive tier list of all the tier lists made on the new forums so far.
I will be updating if any more come out.
Things that went into consideration:
Amount of reactions on the OP:
If you got a lot of negative reactions or a lot of positive ones, it will factor into your placing, this ties into community reception but this is more cut and dry and not subjective.
Amount of apparent effort: Things like comprehensive legends, acknowledging community feedback, and effort put into the list itself are taken into consideration
Community reception: If you had to make a lot of adjustments to your list, it was taken into account. small adjustments are fine and in fact being receptive to suggestions helps you, but if you were way off base to begin with it will hurt. negative comments are also taken into account.
my-image (3).png
Explanations:
S tier:
Toby's Weapon Tier List: By far the most effort put in and the least contested, Toby's tier list is comprehensive and accessible. Is that a FAQ section? Oh Toby, you spoil us! Downsides are this list only received one reaction (mine) but being the tier list with the fewest views accounts for that. Truly underrated.
A Tier:
Lord's Manager Tier List: The OG tier list on the new forums. A good deal of effort went into this, more of a collaborative effort than any of the other lists made, good reception and good acknowledgement of feedback. Cons: drama, exclusion of Lenin
Lord's Permanently Banned Tier List: Lord does it again with another stellar addition to the tier list family. Good initial reception and excellent response to community feedback is a big plus, 12 whole positive reactions is a great plus. No real cons here.
B Tier:
Lord's Staff Tier List: Good tier list overall, pretty much no valid complaints raised in the comments and overall positive community feedback. Less effort went into the ranking criteria as opposed to his manager list which puts it in a lower tier. Cons: less effort overall
Tyber's Server Tier List: Good tier list for sure. Not really any objections raised by the community and good explanations provided for each placement. Formatting of the explanations is a bit messy but this is Tyber we're talking about.
Zaid's List Maker Tier List: not comprehensive in the slightest, but with 8 (!) positive reactions at time of writing, despite being the second least viewed tier list this puts it in a good spot. Cons: missing several list makers, meme list but it payed off
Cameron's Server Tier List: Overall a good list with in my opinion mostly fair placement. Having the thread locked eliminates the chance for any community engagement which hurts this lists placement.
C Tier:
Zaid's MCV Map Tier List: Another quality meme list from Zaid, unfortunately did not receive too too much attention but three positive reactions put this one in a good place
Nate's Staff Tier List: Not a lot of effort went into this, no clarification in the OP, only the list was posted. Purportedly "for the people" but has a lot of adjustments being requested. With an overall neutral reaction score this list sits firmly in the meh category
Cameron's Manager Tier List: Humorous list no doubt. Obvious meme list but unfortunately with a net reaction score of -1 it did not pay off.
D Tier:
Former Staff Tier List: didn't have a very good reception with some people calling it straight up trash. There are still some very questionable placements here and little to no reception of community feedback outside of arbitrarily adding in community impact as a qualifier puts this list pretty low. I'm willing to consider this low C level as well I think it straddles the line.
Putin's Tier List Tier List: Too meta​
 
Last edited:

lord

Browntowns Official Tierlist Maker
Legendary
Donator
Jul 17, 2020
65
29
42
18
Ontario, Canada
Can you add my permanently banned tier list and tyber, nate and lunavis' former staff tier list
 

Zaid_Zilla

Active member
Donator
Jul 17, 2020
42
42
28
Are the rankings in order? As in are the tier lists above the others ones in the tier better?
 

Putin

Active member
Legendary
Donator
Jul 22, 2020
25
23
30
22
Virginia
Are the rankings in order? As in are the tier lists above the others ones in the tier better?
Yeah but pretty loosely, I didn't put an excessive amount of thought into their exact placement into each tier, if you or anyone has suggestions of placements please let me know :)